Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adults Only
3635 Express Dr N, Islandia, 11749, United States
Find the best hotel in Islandia for your dates, by price or preference
Compare deals for Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adults Only across hundreds of sites, all in one place
Look out for a deal with free cancellation or excellent ratings
Compare rooms and prices
We compare 100s of sites to get you the best deal
All taxes and fees included
Fast facts
Check in from: | 16:00 |
|---|---|
Check out before: | 11:00 |
Amenities
Wi-Fi
Parking
Air conditioning
Front desk 24 hour
Restaurant
Non-smoking
More about Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adults Only
Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adults Only
Welcoming guests with stunning glass roof, Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adult Only is located just off the Interstate 495, 2 miles from Long Island Airport. We are an adult only property. You must be 18 to enter hotel and casino.
Ratings and reviews
Cleanliness3.6
Location3.9
Service3.6
Rooms3.6
Value3.3
Sleep quality3.4
Traveller reviews
Filter by
Sort by
Mentioned by travellers
Solo traveller
Comment: 22 Mar 2025
Excellent!!
I always enjoy my stay. Rooms are clean . Staff members extremely pleasant. Front desk staff , especially Thalia and Anthony are always so pleasant and welcoming. Wish I could win though . That would have made my stay over the top but is was truly relaxing and pleasant regardless. :) look forward to my next stay.
Couple
Comment: 23 Apr 2025
Not a real casino by any means
So if you've never been here, this is the current situation. They are building an extension and parking garage. But right now the place is a MESS. I'll explain.
1. Not enough parking at peak times and the valet service is terrible.
2. In order to enter, you must submit to a facial recognition scan and a bag search, go thru metal detection, and possibly an ID scan. Not the way to make you feel welcomed. But they don't care about your comfort.
3. VLTs only (video games and slots). No dealers. Electronic black jack and baccarat. At least roulette uses a real ball. There is really minimal staff inside the casino (except security, which is everywhere).
4. No free beverages. You pay for everything. Money grab to charge for a soda.
5. Many machines broken. Either the volume is broken, the 'play' button is smashed, or the machine doesn't accept your players card. No reason for this, but maintenance here is shoddy.
6. Cashier cage had a tip jar. Really. Is that a joke? Cuz it isn't funny.
7. Zero security outside. I mean NONE. My car got keyed once. Good luck leaving safely if you with a jackpot, there isn't any security of note out there, just the valet kids running around.
8. This used to be a hotel. They converted two floors to become Jake's 58. That being said, there is NO FLOW to anything in there. The entire layout makes no sense. Some parts of the casino are freezing cold, others have little ventilation. It's a very uncomfortable environment in some areas of the building. To enter, you must cross paths to the people leaving. I cannot tell you how annoying this is when it gets crowded, it's like getting on and off a train - people bonking into each other. Inside, there are many areas where placement of the machines makes it 'tight'. At least they got new chairs (finally).
It gets 2 stars because it's better than nothing and it's the county's only casino. But i could be SO much better. If they ever get a competitor, they'll be out of business in no time. Suffolk OTB owns and operates this place and they'll make sure that they keep all the completion away.
1. Not enough parking at peak times and the valet service is terrible.
2. In order to enter, you must submit to a facial recognition scan and a bag search, go thru metal detection, and possibly an ID scan. Not the way to make you feel welcomed. But they don't care about your comfort.
3. VLTs only (video games and slots). No dealers. Electronic black jack and baccarat. At least roulette uses a real ball. There is really minimal staff inside the casino (except security, which is everywhere).
4. No free beverages. You pay for everything. Money grab to charge for a soda.
5. Many machines broken. Either the volume is broken, the 'play' button is smashed, or the machine doesn't accept your players card. No reason for this, but maintenance here is shoddy.
6. Cashier cage had a tip jar. Really. Is that a joke? Cuz it isn't funny.
7. Zero security outside. I mean NONE. My car got keyed once. Good luck leaving safely if you with a jackpot, there isn't any security of note out there, just the valet kids running around.
8. This used to be a hotel. They converted two floors to become Jake's 58. That being said, there is NO FLOW to anything in there. The entire layout makes no sense. Some parts of the casino are freezing cold, others have little ventilation. It's a very uncomfortable environment in some areas of the building. To enter, you must cross paths to the people leaving. I cannot tell you how annoying this is when it gets crowded, it's like getting on and off a train - people bonking into each other. Inside, there are many areas where placement of the machines makes it 'tight'. At least they got new chairs (finally).
It gets 2 stars because it's better than nothing and it's the county's only casino. But i could be SO much better. If they ever get a competitor, they'll be out of business in no time. Suffolk OTB owns and operates this place and they'll make sure that they keep all the completion away.
Comment: 30 Mar 2025
Stayed in: Mar 2025
Smh. The bathroom in the room was disgusting. I made a complaint. After I made the complaint, I received a call stating there will be no hot water from 4am to 12noon
Family traveller
Comment: 22 Mar 2025
Still don’t like the downgrade since OTB took over
As of my review in April 2023 BELOW
Your hotel staff especially Suzanne is more than welcoming and checking in to make sure that our room is comfortable. We eat at the bistro but they’ve changed the menu on that a few times. I know they’re going through construction so parking is definitely an issue which is expected. My room was clean and comfortable. Like I said my review from 2023 was answered by Ashley and have never seen that quote. I’ll take care of you the next visit”
We are back in New York, so we don’t utilize the hotel as much as we used to, but do try to make it back once or twice a month until my husband retires. But then again like I said, never got that quote. I’ll take care of you on the next visit“ Thank you Suzanne and Hotel reception staff. We appreciate you. Ann McKendry
We have been coming to Jakes for years more in the last two years since we moved to Pennsylvania. We have gambled enough to bring ourselves up to two comps a week per person spending the same amount of cash each time. Now they have somehow changed the criteria. We are down to one room each. We visit family often and find that Jakes has always been the go to place for having fun and earning comp rooms at the same time. Are we going to lose the one night a week per person each now? I have spoken to many people who are in the same situation as us and now we will end up having to find and give our money to another hotel chain. Just so Jakes can renovate their hotel. We have never ever had a problem staying there along with the hotel staff are wonderful and have always been accommodating to my “feather free room” request. We walk in they know us by first names as do we know theirs. We may not spend tens of thousands of dollars but we are loyal customers of your establishment. Unfortunately that may have to change. Please reconsider your criteria as I am sure we are not the only one that will be affected by this and disappointed as well. “THE MCKENDRYS” as we are welcomed by your front desk staff. Ann Mckendry
Your hotel staff especially Suzanne is more than welcoming and checking in to make sure that our room is comfortable. We eat at the bistro but they’ve changed the menu on that a few times. I know they’re going through construction so parking is definitely an issue which is expected. My room was clean and comfortable. Like I said my review from 2023 was answered by Ashley and have never seen that quote. I’ll take care of you the next visit”
We are back in New York, so we don’t utilize the hotel as much as we used to, but do try to make it back once or twice a month until my husband retires. But then again like I said, never got that quote. I’ll take care of you on the next visit“ Thank you Suzanne and Hotel reception staff. We appreciate you. Ann McKendry
We have been coming to Jakes for years more in the last two years since we moved to Pennsylvania. We have gambled enough to bring ourselves up to two comps a week per person spending the same amount of cash each time. Now they have somehow changed the criteria. We are down to one room each. We visit family often and find that Jakes has always been the go to place for having fun and earning comp rooms at the same time. Are we going to lose the one night a week per person each now? I have spoken to many people who are in the same situation as us and now we will end up having to find and give our money to another hotel chain. Just so Jakes can renovate their hotel. We have never ever had a problem staying there along with the hotel staff are wonderful and have always been accommodating to my “feather free room” request. We walk in they know us by first names as do we know theirs. We may not spend tens of thousands of dollars but we are loyal customers of your establishment. Unfortunately that may have to change. Please reconsider your criteria as I am sure we are not the only one that will be affected by this and disappointed as well. “THE MCKENDRYS” as we are welcomed by your front desk staff. Ann Mckendry
Family traveller
Comment: 6 Mar 2025
Good times
Jake58 Hotel and Casino is beautiful, and the location is very convenient with thousands of slot machines and table games to keep you busy, the hotel rooms are very comfortable and the bed and pillows are great. The location is about 1 1/2 - 2hrs from the five boroughs
Location
3635 Express Dr N, Islandia, 11749, United States|0.74 km from city centre
10 things to dowithin 1.52 km
Check in and check out
Check in from:
16:00
Check out before:
11:00
Good to know
Please contact the hotel for details about adding extra beds.
Please contact the hotel for details about adding a cot.
Guests are required to show a photo identification and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply. In response to Coronavirus (COVID-19), additional safety and sanitation measures are in effect at this property. Due to Coronavirus (COVID-19), this property is taking steps to help protect the safety of guests and staff. Certain services and amenities may be reduced or unavailable as a result. Due to Coronavirus (COVID-19), this property has reduced reception and service operating hours. Upon check-in photo identification and credit card is required. All special requests are subject to availability upon check-in. Special requests cannot be guaranteed and may incur additional charges. Government-issued photo identification and a credit card may be required at check-in for incidental charges. Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino is an adult only property. We do not allow children on property. We are 18 and older to enter the facility. Guests be 21 years old or older to check into the hotel.
Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adults Only: FAQs
Need flights or a car for your trip?
Did you know we can help you plan the rest of your trip? Get exclusive deals and great rates for flights and car hire.Flights
Car hire in Islandia
